
The last time I finished a book during our company’s annual convention was in 2007 when I polished off Jerzy Kosinski’s The Painted Bird in a day and a half. In spite of the controversy concerning the author and authenticity of that book, I highly recommend it for the very fanciful horror of the story. It’s hard to describe it in any other way. To this day there is a swirl of controversy surrounding the story. Simply view it as a work of fiction and you’ll be fine. Even as a work of fiction, it’s an amazing read.
Over the subsequent years, hi-ever, free wi-fi has interrupted any casual reading. I need to shore up my reading resolve in such circumstances and not fall prey to the easy fix of the internet. This year that resolve was forced upon me since the room I was residing over did not include a reachable wi-fi signal.
Not to worry, I carried along a reading companion I was sure would captivate my attention. And captivate it did, finished in a day with a lovely glass of wine to spare. It is, as they say, an easy read. Quite delightful. In spite of the page turning party that engulfed me, I can’t give this book and over the top glowing review.
Since I don’t consider myself a particularly good reviewer of anything, I’ll just break it all down in the pros and cons:
The Pros
I found myself chuckling out loud many times
Much of the prose was clever and beguiling
In this case, an epistolary approach to the story was quite effective
It makes me want to travel to Guernsey and meet the people in spite of their fictional status
I was completely enthralled by the story of the Elizabeth McKenna and wish there was a companion novel entirely about her
Reading didn’t stop until I reached the last page
I want a taste of a potato peel pie
The Cons
The characters were not particularly authentic – they were certainly charming, but unfortunately they fell into one of three categories – good, bad or intolerantly annoying. For instance, one of the characters was an overt, opinionated, uncaring Christian. I am an atheist, and while I find the hypocrisy of some Christians to be annoying at best and evil at worst, I find the one dimensional view of ‘the intolerant Christian’ to be short sighted and bigoted. Add to that the good Nazi, the stoic stalwart, the precocious child and the American cad and you have a formula for predictability.
The bottom line
In spite of the cons, I completely enjoyed this book and wish my copy was not owned by the library. The abundance of bon mots and insights make this a highlighter party of a read. The underlying story of the heroine gives the book some much needed depth.
Waste of time scale
1= I totally wasted my time. When I’m near death I’ll wish I had that time back to eat ice cream, get drunk and screw
5 = I won’t really curse myself for taking time out of my life for this, but I’m not exactly jumping for joy over the time expenditure
10= This has enriched my life, I am a better person and it was totally worth my time.
WOT Scale = 7